Sample optimality in the design of stated choice experiments Submitted
نویسندگان
چکیده
Recent research by Bliemer and Rose (2005, 2009, in press) and Rose and Bliemer (2005) suggest as a measure for calculating sample size requirements for models estimated using stated choice data, the S-error statistic. Prior to this, existing sampling theories failed to adequately address the issue of sample size requirements specifically for this type of data and hence researchers have had to resort to simple rules of thumb or ignore the issue and collect samples of arbitrary size, hoping that the sample is sufficiently large enough to produce reliable parameter estimates. In this paper, we explore the sample size calculations proposed by Bliemer and Rose and demonstrate how these measures may be used to suggest a theoretical minimum sample size, assuming prior parameter values used in generating experiments. Sample size requirements for different model types are explored via three different case studies. The paper finds that the S-error statistic provides a robust estimate of the minimum sample size requirements for stated choice studies, however it is recommended that larger sample sizes than suggested by the statistic be collected to allow for different sources of misspecification that can occur during the course of such studies.
منابع مشابه
On Rank-Ordered Nested Multinomial Logit Model and D-Optimal Design for this Model
In contrast to the classical discrete choice experiment, the respondent in a rank-order discrete choice experiment, is asked to rank a number of alternatives instead of the preferred one. In this paper, we study the information matrix of a rank order nested multinomial logit model (RO.NMNL) and introduce local D-optimality criterion, then we obtain Locally D-optimal design for RO.NMNL models in...
متن کاملConstructing Efficient Stated Choice Experimental Designs
Stated choice experiments are often used in transportation studies for estimating and forecasting behavior of travelers, road authorities, etc. This kind of experiments rely on underlying experimental designs. Whilst orthogonal designs are mainstream for practitioners, many researchers now realize that so-called efficient designs are able to produce more efficient data in the sense that more re...
متن کاملITLS - WP - 08 - 12 Efficient stated choice experiments for estimating nested logit models By
The allocation of combinations of attribute levels to choice situations in stated choice (SC) experiments can have a significant influence upon the resulting study outputs once data is collected. Recently, a small but growing stream of research has looked at using what have become known as efficient SC experimental designs to allocate the attribute levels to choice situations in a manner design...
متن کاملDeveloping attributes and levels for a discrete choice experiment on basic health insurance in Iran
Background: Nonmarket stated preferences valuation, especially discrete choice experiments (DCEs), is one of the commonly used techniques in the health sector. The primary purpose of this approach is to help select attributes and attributes-levels that are able to properly describe health care products or services. This study aimed at developing attributes and attributes-levels for basic health...
متن کاملConstructing an Optimal Orthogonal Choice Design with Alternative-specific Attributes for Stated Choice Experiments
1 The stated choice (SC) experiment is generally regarded as an effective way to obtain data for 2 discrete choice analysis. The SC experimental design method, which determines the rule to allocate 3 different levels for each attribute in choice situations, will have a great impact on parameter 4 estimation. The optimal orthogonal choice (OOC) design is one of the most efficient SC designs, by ...
متن کامل